Warning Fatigue: Why People Ignore Alerts and What Research Suggests

warning fatigue

Tired of alerts you’ve started to swipe away? Warning fatigue is when too many, irrelevant or confusing alerts make people tune out, and research points to frequency, relevance and message content as the main drivers.

This page belongs to the wider topic of emergency management, where public warning is one part of planning and response.

Item Value
Sutton and Wood paper on over-alerting, publication year 2025
Antecedents of warning fatigue named in that paper Alert frequency, relevancy, message content
Date of Israel’s false earthquake early warning alert October 26, 2024
Magnitude wrongly assigned to the explosion Magnitude 5.2
People who received that alert More than one million people
Follow-up survey sample N = 1,043

These figures come from the Albany scholars archive record and the Scientific Reports paper on PMC. Figures can change or be revised, so check the sources before you rely on them.

What warning fatigue means

Warning fatigue is the label emergency managers use when people stop responding to the alerts they receive. A paper by Sutton and Wood, published in 2025 in the Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, notes that practitioners commonly describe it as a problem due to over-alerting, which leads to opting out. The authors add that there has been limited research defining these ideas in a systematic way, as the Albany archive abstract explains.

To build definitions, the team drew on interviews with emergency managers and open-ended survey answers from both emergency managers and members of the public. Their focus was Wireless Emergency Alerts (WEA), the messages sent to phones.

What research says causes it

The Albany study sorts its findings into three groups, which you can see in the list below, according to the archive abstract.

  • Antecedents (what leads to it): alert frequency, relevancy and message content.
  • Symptoms: mental strain, emotional and physiological stress, and evaluative fatigue.
  • Consequences: desensitization, complaining and opting out.

The authors argue that mapping these dimensions makes it possible to identify the true drivers behind decisions to turn off or tune out emergency alerts. Read plainly, a high volume of messages is only part of the story, because whether a message feels relevant and how it is worded also count.

What a false alert in Israel showed

On October 26, 2024, a planned military explosion was mistakenly classified as a magnitude 5.2 earthquake by Israel’s early warning system, triggering alerts to over one million people. The Scientific Reports paper describes it as the first-ever public alert from that system in Israel, and says it came during wartime, after a year of near-daily missile alerts. That makes it a rare real-world test of a false alert.

Researchers ran a preregistered survey (N = 1,043) shortly after the event. Because the alert was geographically limited, they could compare attitudes between people who received it and people who did not, as the paper reports.

Respondents largely stayed motivated to follow guidance and showed considerable tolerance for false alerts. That tolerance was significantly lower for false earthquake alerts than for false missile alerts, which the authors tie to different public perceptions of seismic and security threats.

A hand holds a smartphone upright in a bright room.

How repeated false alarms wear down trust

In Carnation, Washington, a warning-system siren for the Tolt Dam blared for more than 40 minutes in the first of eight false alarms over a four-year span, according to Nautilus. The report says a crew working on the warning system had accidentally set it off. It is a vivid case of a false alarm with lasting effects.

In August 2023, after the sixth failure of the alarm, the city declared a state of emergency and urged Seattle officials to fix the problem. One resident, Collienne Becker, told the magazine: “Waiting is probably not the right decision, but I just don’t trust it anymore.”

This is anecdotal rather than systematic evidence. Still, it shows how repeated errors can push people toward waiting and checking instead of acting at once, a pattern the Nautilus report links to a loss of trust.

What the research suggests for alert design

Designers face a trade-off. The Israeli paper says policymakers use a magnitude threshold above which alerts are sent, aiming to balance urgency and necessity, and that a low threshold could lead to frequent over-alerting, according to the PMC article.

The same paper says that if people do not trust a warning system, they may ignore instructions or even disable the alerts entirely. Nautilus frames the design question as weighing the consequences of too many alarms versus too few, so trust sits at the centre of the problem.

Warning systems still matter. A World Meteorological Organization report cited by Nautilus found that reported weather-related disasters rose almost fivefold from 1970 to 2019, while deaths from them dropped by a factor of three. The WMO attributes the higher survival rates to improved disaster management and more early warning systems.

Deciding which hazards justify a public alert is partly a risk question, and a hazard vulnerability assessment is one way planners structure it. Because message content is one of the antecedents the Albany study names, readers interested in who can actually perceive a message can read about accessible emergency alerts on this site.

How can you cope with alert overload?

None of the sources tested personal coping steps, so treat these as cautious pointers. Your local emergency authorities are the right place to ask about alert settings and what to do when a warning arrives.

  • Ask your local authority which alerts are meant for your area and how it labels tests. In Carnation, according to Nautilus, locals learn that an alarm on Wednesday at noon is routine testing.
  • If a message seems irrelevant or confusing, note why. Relevancy and message content are two antecedents in the Albany study, and the issuing authority is the one that can change them.
  • Think before opting out. In the Israeli survey, public support for receiving warnings stayed strong even for non-damaging events that people felt, as the paper reports.

Frequently asked questions

Is warning fatigue the same as alert fatigue?

Show answer

In everyday use the two terms overlap. The Israeli paper speaks of alert fatigue and disengagement after false or unnecessary alerts, while the Albany paper builds its definition of warning fatigue from causes, symptoms and outcomes (PMC).

Is warning fatigue only about getting too many alerts?

Show answer

No. Frequency is one driver, but the researchers also point to whether a message feels relevant and how it is worded (Albany archive).

Does one false alert destroy public trust?

Show answer

Not necessarily. In the Israeli survey, support for receiving alerts, even for events people could feel but that caused no damage, remained strong. The authors still describe false alerts as a critical concern for policymakers (PMC).

Should I switch off alerts on my phone if they feel like too much?

Show answer

Follow the guidance of your local emergency authorities before changing settings. Researchers treat turning alerts off as a harmful outcome of fatigue, not a fix for it (Albany archive).